SPOILER-FREE FILM REVIEWS FROM A MOVIE LOVER WITH A HEART OF GOLD!

From the land of 10,000 lakes comes a fan of 10,000 movies!

Directed By David Lean Volume Two Blu-ray Review: Boots, Jets and Gondolas

Directed By David Lean Volume Two Blu-ray cover art

Directed By David Lean Volume Two (1949-1955)

Blu-ray · Imprint Films

Shelf Worthy

In Brief

Imprint Films gathers five David Lean films made between 1949 and 1955, moving from Ann Todd melodramas through jet-age drama, Lancashire comedy, and Katharine Hepburn in Venice. Strong transfers, new commentaries, and a bonus disc make this six-disc limited hardbox Shelf Worthy.

The Facts

Synopsis: Five David Lean films from 1949 to 1955: a romantic triangle, a Victorian murder trial, a race to fly faster than sound, a Lancashire family comedy, and a lonely American’s summer in Venice.

Starring: Ann Todd, Claude Rains, Trevor Howard, Ralph Richardson, Charles Laughton, Katharine Hepburn

Directed by: David Lean

Rated: Not Rated

Running Length: The Passionate Friends 91 minutes; Madeleine 115 minutes; The Sound Barrier 117 minutes; Hobson’s Choice 108 minutes; Summertime 100 minutes

Buy It Here

The Package

Label: Imprint Films

Format: Blu-ray

Release Date: January 7, 2026

Video: 1080p. Four films in black and white at or near 1.37:1 (Madeleine listed at 1.33:1). Summertime in color from a 4K restoration, reportedly offered in both 1.37:1 and 1.78:1. The Sound Barrier from the BFI’s 2018 restoration of the British version

Audio: English LPCM 2.0 mono on all five films

Subtitles: English HOH

Discs: 6 discs: one Blu-ray per film plus a bonus disc, Imprint Collection #521-525. Limited-edition hardbox of 1,500 copies with a 70-page hardcover booklet. Region B

The Film

Ann Todd stars in three of the five movies here, and the reason is a love story of its own. David Lean fell for her while making The Passionate Friends when both were married to other people. They eventually married, and Madeleine became, in large part, his wedding present to her. Anyone opening this box expecting deserts, railways, and thousands of extras is a few years early. The Bridge on the River Kwai was still two years away when this collection ends in Venice.

The Passionate Friends (1949), adapted from H. G. Wells, finds Todd (The Seventh Veil) as a married woman who unexpectedly reconnects with the former lover she left behind (Trevor Howard, Brief Encounter). Claude Rains (Casablanca) plays the wealthy husband who realizes something has shifted. Lean took over after production stalled under Ronald Neame, and the finished film lost money. The nested flashback structure drew complaints, but the emotional triangle gives all three actors room to hurt one another without turning anyone into a simple villain.

Madeleine (1950) makes its worldwide Blu-ray debut in this box. Todd reprises the role she had played onstage, portraying Madeleine Smith, the Glasgow woman tried in 1857 for murdering her secret lover. Leslie Banks plays her father in his final film. Lean later dismissed Madeleine as his worst picture, although later critics have been more willing to defend its control, ambiguity, and claustrophobic view of Victorian respectability.

The Sound Barrier (1952) leaves drawing rooms behind for test pilots and jet engines. Ralph Richardson (Doctor Zhivago) plays aircraft manufacturer John Ridgefield, a man determined to build a plane capable of breaking the sound barrier, while his daughter Susan (Todd) increasingly questions what that obsession is costing the people around him. Terence Rattigan wrote the screenplay, and real jets filmed at an English airfield give the flying sequences an immediacy studio work could not fake. The film won BAFTA’s Best Film and an Academy Award for sound before gradually becoming one of Lean’s less frequently seen titles.

Hobson’s Choice (1954) is the warmest movie in the collection. Henry Hobson (Charles Laughton, The Private Life of Henry VIII) expects his three daughters to run his Salford boot shop without wages or complaints. His eldest, Maggie (Brenda de Banzie, The Pink Panther), has other ideas and essentially chooses the meek bootmaker Will Mossop (John Mills, Ryan’s Daughter) as her husband before he has fully processed the news. Malcolm Arnold scores Hobson’s drunken moonlit wander with a musical saw. Laughton plays a household tyrant, and Lean somehow makes him impossible to hate.

Summertime (1955) closes the set in color and on location. Katharine Hepburn (The African Queen) plays Jane Hudson, a lonely American taking her first trip to Venice, where she falls for a charming local man (Rossano Brazzi, South Pacific) and then learns he is married. Lean shot extensively in the city and later called the movie his favorite of his own work. It earned Academy Award nominations for both Lean and Hepburn, and the film’s romantic image of Venice reportedly helped send tourism climbing.

What makes the collection interesting is watching Lean’s scale expand without his interests changing as much as you might expect. Whether he is filming a marriage, a murder trial, a test plane, a boot shop, or Venice itself, he remains fascinated by people choosing between what they want and what the world expects of them. The epics are coming. The filmmaker is already here.

The Transfer

Video

All five films are presented in 1080p, with the four black-and-white features retaining their original Academy-style framing. The transfers are quite strong overall, giving these earlier David Lean films the kind of attention they deserve. The Passionate Friends is arguably the least impressive of the bunch, but even that presentation holds its own alongside the others. Madeleine and Hobson’s Choice benefit from strong detail and satisfying black levels, allowing the cinematography to shine without losing the natural texture of the original film elements. The Sound Barrier also looks terrific, with its BFI restoration delivering clean contrast and a nicely balanced black-and-white image. There’s a little wear here and there, but nothing that seriously detracts from the experience. The real visual treat is Summertime, which benefits from a 4K restoration that brings new life to Jack Hildyard’s gorgeous Venetian photography. The colors, architecture, and sunlit canals are a feast for the eyes, reminding us just how much of the film’s romantic appeal comes from its spectacular setting. Venice practically becomes another character, and the improved presentation makes it all the more inviting.

Audio

Each film includes its original English mono soundtrack in LPCM 2.0, along with English subtitles for the hard of hearing. The tracks offer clear dialogue and preserve the character of their original theatrical presentations without introducing unnecessary surround sound remixes. There’s something particularly satisfying about hearing these films in their original audio configurations, especially when it comes to Malcolm Arnold’s memorable music for Hobson’s Choice and The Sound Barrier. The soundtracks may not have the bells and whistles of modern productions, but they don’t need them. Everything is presented with the simplicity and clarity these films deserve.

Transfer Notes

There are a few interesting distinctions between the restorations and versions included in this collection. Madeleine comes courtesy of ITV, while Hobson’s Choice uses an earlier StudioCanal restoration. The Sound Barrier is presented in its 117-minute British version rather than the shorter American release, which was retitled Breaking the Sound Barrier. Summertime also gets a particularly welcome addition, with both 1.37:1 and 1.78:1 presentations available. That gives collectors a choice of framing, something not offered on Criterion’s U.S. Blu-ray, which features the film exclusively at 1.37:1. It’s a nice bonus for anyone interested in comparing how the composition changes between the two versions.

All five Blu-rays are Region B, so U.S. collectors will need a Region B-compatible or region-free Blu-ray player to enjoy this collection. It’s an important consideration before importing, especially for anyone accustomed to purchasing domestic Criterion editions. What makes this set so appealing is the opportunity to experience five films from an extraordinary director in one collection. With strong HD presentations, original mono soundtracks, and some interesting variations from previous releases, it’s a handsome way to revisit these films or discover them for the first time.

Special Features

  • Audio Commentaries by Alain Silver and Jim Ursini (NEW): Included on every film except Hobson’s Choice.
  • Appreciations by Professor Melanie Williams (NEW): A separate discussion for each of the five films.
  • Jim Pople Interviews (NEW): The first assistant editor discusses The Passionate Friends and Madeleine.
  • Douglas Barr and Michael Medwin Interviews (NEW): Additional production memories on the Madeleine disc.
  • Painting the Sky: Peter Mullins Remembers The Sound Barrier (NEW): The scenic artist revisits the film’s production.
  • BFI Interview with David Lean (1959) and Geoffrey Wansell Interview: Archival material included with The Sound Barrier.
  • Prunella Scales and Norman Spencer Interviews: Carried over from StudioCanal’s 2014 Hobson’s Choice release.
  • Audio Commentary by Mark Nicholls: A second commentary option for Summertime.
  • Summertime 1.78:1 Presentation: An alternate widescreen version reported in published technical coverage.
  • Before the Epic: David Lean’s Little Gems, Part Two (NEW): Simon Lewis’s 2025 documentary continues the story begun in Imprint’s first Lean box.
  • David Lean: A Self Portrait (1971): A vintage profile of the director.
  • The South Bank Show (1985 and 1990): David Lean: A Life in Film and David Lean and Robert Bolt.
  • Stills Galleries and Trailers: Archival material spread across the film discs.
  • 70-Page Hardcover Booklet: Includes four chapters from Alain Silver and Jim Ursini’s The Films of David Lean.

The bonus disc and Melanie Williams’ appreciations turn the box into a compact Lean course rather than just a stack of movies. Collectors may still want to keep Kino’s The Sound Barrier and Criterion’s Summertime because some edition-specific material did not carry over.

Shelf Worthy?

Shelf Worthy

Lean devotees, British-film fans, and anyone who knows the director mainly from his giant-screen epics should find plenty to love here. The box catches him in the stretch before The Bridge on the River Kwai, when he was already working with major stars and increasingly ambitious production values but could still build an entire movie around a marriage, a family business, or one lonely tourist.

The price is substantial, and the Blu-rays are Region B, which U.S. buyers should keep in mind before importing. Budget-minded viewers can sample Summertime or Hobson’s Choice first. Anyone ready to dig deeper into Lean gets an unusually rich collection. Lawrence of Arabia can wait. Start in Salford, end in Venice.

Shelf Worthy: Buy it. This one earns a spot on the shelf.

Stream First: Watch it before you buy.

Completionists Only: For collectors who need every edition.

Imprint Films provided a copy for review. My opinions are my own.

Joe Botten, The MN Movie Man

Reviewed by Joe Botten

Joe Botten is The MN Movie Man, a Twin Cities film critic writing spoiler-free reviews since 2012. He also writes for Loud and Clear Reviews, a Rotten Tomatoes approved site. Find him on Instagram and Letterboxd.

Looking for something?

Search by actor, movie, director, genre or keyword.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 5,237 other subscribers
Where to watch Hobson's Choice

Leave a Reply