Synopsis: Her family slaughtered. Her home in ash. Chosen by a goddess and forged in fire, a warrior rises to hunt the queen who took everything, before a cursed talisman erases the world from existence.
Stars: Brigitte Nielsen, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Sandahl Bergman
Director: Richard Fleischer
Rated:PG-13
Running Length: 89 minutes
Movie Review in Brief: Arrow Video’s Red Sonja 4K UHD Limited Edition is a beautiful restoration of a deeply uneven 1985 sword-and-sorcery flop. The disc deserves a Shelf Worthy verdict. The film earns Stream First.
Review: A Bad Movie That Refuses to Bore
Let’s clear the air. Red Sonja is not a good movie. Schwarzenegger himself uses it as a discipline tool for his kids—claiming the threat of watching it ten times in a row keeps them in line. Maria Shriver leaned over at the premiere and told him that if this didn’t kill his career, nothing would. Gene Siskel summed it up as a bad film that was unintentionally funny. And yet, four decades on, this sword-and-sorcery cash-in still delivers a kind of entertainment value that has nothing to do with quality and everything to do with charm. Arrow Video’s new 4K release makes the case for restoration regardless of merit, and the case lands.
The Film: Producer Dino De Laurentiis Strikes Again
Producer Dino De Laurentiis spent nearly a year hunting for an actress “Amazonian” enough to play Robert E. Howard‘s warrior. Eight weeks before cameras rolled, he found Brigitte Nielsen on the cover of a fashion magazine. The 21-year-old Danish model got the role, an on-set affair with Schwarzenegger, a feud with Sandahl Bergman, and the kind of debut the industry doesn’t easily forget. Sigourney Weaver had been considered. Eileen Davidson was reportedly the runner-up. Laurene Landon nearly had the part until De Laurentiis discovered she’d already starred in the similar Hundra two years earlier. The casting churn never quite resolved itself.
The plot of Red Sonja runs on autopilot. Evil Queen Gedren (Bergman, Conan the Barbarian) wants a magic orb. Sonja (Nielsen) wants revenge after Gedren slaughters her family. Kalidor (Schwarzenegger, playing a barely-renamed Conan because the rights weren’t there) tries to help. Sword fights and creature effects ensue. Ernie Reyes Jr. shows up as a martial-arts-trained prince and steals every scene he’s in. Cast for his fighting skills, the script was rewritten to make room for them.
Director Richard Fleischer turns in journeyman work. The real failure is that production designer Danilo Donati‘s stunning sets get filmed like they’re a parking lot. Nielsen’s wooden performance can’t carry the title role, and the contrast with Bergman’s grace, particularly in their face-off, is brutal. Initially, the casting was reversed: Bergman was originally offered Sonja and turned it down to avoid typecasting after her role in Conan. Watching the film, that decision plays as career suicide for Bergman and a missed opportunity for the whole project. There’s an additional bit of subtext for genre fans: Bergman played Schwarzenegger’s love interest in Conan the Barbarian, Nielsen plays it here, so their final duel doubles as a fight over Arnold himself.
Poor Arnold. Schwarzenegger thought he was signing on for a glorified cameo as a favor to De Laurentiis. He was on set for four weeks instead of the one he’d agreed to, and only realized his role had been greatly expanded to that of co-star when he watched the rough cut. He terminated his De Laurentiis contract soon after.
What saves Red Sonja is Schwarzenegger having visibly more fun here than he did in Conan the Destroyer, Reyes Jr.’s spark, and an Ennio Morricone score that does more storytelling than the script. The mechanical-serpent showdown is the standout, sold by performance alone, complete with Kalidor’s wink to the audience that he can’t kill the creature because it’s a machine, a definite nod to a certain previous Schwarzenegger role released only the year before.
The Disc: Arrow Restores What the Movie Couldn't
Arrow’s 4K restoration from the original negative gets a new HDR grade specifically for this release, presented in Dolby Vision with HDR10 compatibility. Giuseppe Rotunno‘s cinematography looks better than the film deserves, which is exactly the point of these boutique restorations. Color pops without oversaturation. Black levels and contrast reveal detail in Donati’s production design that prior home releases buried. The image is clean from start to finish.
Audio runs original lossless mono and an optional DTS-HD MA 5.1 surround. Morricone’s score gets the breathing room it needs, and the surround mix gives the action sequences directional clarity they always lacked.
Extras: An Education in Italian Co-Productions
The supplement package is genuinely wild given the film’s reputation. Two new commentaries lead the way: critics Eugenio Ercolani and Troy Howarth on one, comic-book expert Dave Baxter on the other. Then a parade of new interviews unfolds: Ernie Reyes Jr. on auditioning with martial arts demonstrations, action unit supervisor Vic Armstrong on working with Schwarzenegger from this film through to the current Lord of the Rings series, and stunt doubles and assistant production managers offering Italian-film-industry history that doubles as a master class in mid-’80s De Laurentiis productions.
Pietro Torrisi’s twenty-six-minute interview is pure character-actor gold. Domingo Lizcano’s piece on the late FX artist Emilio Ruiz del RĂo is a small documentary on a vanished craft. There’s even an archival interview with poster artist Renato Casaro, whose work for Rambo III, The Running Man, and this film helped define the visual language of ’80s action marketing.
A reversible sleeve, fold-out poster, six art cards, and a perfect-bound booklet with new writing complete a package that treats this disposable cash-grab like a piece of cinema history—which, after forty years, it kind of is.
Where It Lands
Stream First. The film is too uneven to demand a place on most shelves, but the disc does heroic work on a movie that doesn’t entirely earn it. Curious cult-film viewers will get plenty of mileage, and Schwarzenegger completists already know the answer.
Looking for something? Search for it here! Try an actor, movie, director, genre, or keyword!
