Synopsis:Julie and Billy, two jaded aspiring comedians who live together in New York City, navigate through their thirties while dealing with their individual careers and personal relationships.
Stars: Julie Klausner, Billy Eichner, James Urbaniak, Andrea Martin, Derrick Baskin, Gabourey Sidibe, Cole Escola, Bridget Everett
Directors: Jeffrey Walker, Andrew Fleming, Neil Daly, Scott King
Rated: TV-MA
Running Length: 28 30min episodes
Movie Review in Brief: Universal’s Difficult People Blu-ray collects all 28 episodes of Julie Klausner and Billy Eichner’s fearless Hulu comedy, with a crisp transfer and small but fun extras. Shelf Worthy, and three seasons still wasn’t enough.
Buy it here
The Right Show at Exactly the Wrong Moment
August 2015 was a strange turning point in the culture. The optimism was draining out of the room, and into that mood walked a comedy ready to meet the creeping bitterness head-on and build an entire worldview out of it. Difficult People premiered on Hulu with executive producer Amy Poehler trading the warm civic faith of Parks and Recreation for something sourer, sharper, and a lot meaner. Universal’s Difficult People Blu-ray gathers all 28 episodes of a show that ran three seasons, got cut down before its time, and only looks smarter with each passing year.
Two Comedians, One Grudge Against Everything
Julie Kessler (Julie Klausner) and Billy Epstein (Billy Eichner) are struggling New York comedians who hate nearly everything except each other.
The industry ignores them, their peers keep booking the sitcoms and movies they covet, and they respond the only way they know how: with bile, recaps, and the occasional career-torching joke about the wrong celebrity. Klausner, a podcaster and writer who went on to pen what I consider the single best episode of Apple’s Schmigadoon! (“Bells and Whistles” in Season 2), created the series and writes Julie and Billy as fictionalized versions of herself and Eichner (Bros). That autobiographical streak gives the cruelty a foundation. These two aren’t mean for shock value. They’re mean because the world is unfair and complaining together is the truest form of friendship they have.
That loyalty is what powers the show. The bitterness isn’t the joke; the friendship underneath it is. Klausner and Eichner play off each other like people who have been finishing each other’s insults for years, and the writing got sharper every season from an already high starting point.
A Bench Stacked Deeper Than the Two Leads
The supporting cast carries as much of the load as the stars. James Urbaniak (Oppenheimer) is perfectly cast as Arthur, Julie’s endlessly patient PBS-employed boyfriend who calls her a rotating list of nicknames that closed captioning openly gave up trying to track. Andrea Martin (Overcompensating) walks off with scenes as Julie’s “self-inclined” narcissist mother, one of the best comedic showcases of her refreshingly fun late-career run. Gabourey Sidibe clearly relishes the chance to be funny as Billy’s boss Denise, and a young Cole Escola turns the bratty coworker Matthew into a scene-stealing audition for the stardom that Oh, Mary! would later confirm.
There’s another kind of importance running under the show too. Difficult People handed major roles to trans and non-binary performers and characters and never treated it as a gold star to be collected. Shakina Nayfack‘s Lola is a trans 9/11 truther, written as a full comic creation rather than a lesson. That casual inclusivity, paired with jokes that were a beat ahead of where the culture would land, is a big part of why the show paved the way for series like Search Party and The Other Two. It was fearless about who and what it would mock, and a decade on, an unsettling number of those punchlines look like predictions.
Then there are the guest stars, a parade of famous faces showing up to be insulted or to play warped versions of themselves: Tina Fey, Martin Short, Julianne Moore, Lin-Manuel Miranda at the absolute peak of Hamilton mania, John Mulaney as a penny-farthing-riding “old timey,” Kate McKinnon as a sober magician, Nathan Lane, Lucy Liu, John Turturro, Method Man, and Ken Burns, among many others. The roster reads like a who’s who of mid-2010s comedy, and almost all of them are game to look ridiculous.
A New York You Recognize but Rarely See
Across all 28 episodes, the Difficult People Blu-ray delivers exactly the kind of clean, modern presentation the show deserves. Difficult People was shot crisp and sharp, and the disc has strong source material to work from. The picture is bright and detailed, with the kind of natural clarity that lets a fast, dialogue-heavy comedy breathe. Color is accurate and lifelike, skin tones look right, and the show’s New York comes through with real texture. This is a city the series knows well, less the postcard Manhattan tourists picture and more the working corners around Julie’s apartment, the restaurant, and the off-center neighborhoods where most of the comedy actually lives.
Worth noting for the format-curious: each season had its own cinematographer, with Steven Capitano Calitri on season one, Jon Delgado on season two, and Martin McGrath on season three, so the look shifts subtly across the run rather than holding to one signature. The audio is a clean, dialogue-forward comedy mix, which is exactly what this material needs. Every rapid-fire exchange, muttered aside, and pop-culture deep cut comes through with clarity, and the busy New York soundscapes fill in around the edges without ever stepping on a punchline. For a show that lives and dies on people talking fast, the dialogue never gets lost. Optional English SDH subtitles are included for every episode, which feels essential for a series this verbal.
Small but Genuinely Fun Extras
The bonus features are a modest spread, and most of them are worth your time. The highlight is a set of episode commentaries with Klausner and Eichner on “Library Water,” “Italian Piñata,” and “Strike Rat.” They’re a blast, exactly the loose, funny, gossipy hangout you’d want from these two, and my only real complaint is that there aren’t more of them. Commentary on all 28 episodes would have been a dream. The 2015 Vulture Festival panel with Poehler, Klausner, and Eichner is a nice time capsule, and one of the best critics working today, Matt Zoller Seitz, contributes a video essay, “An Ode to a Beautiful Friendship,” that takes the show and its central relationship as seriously as they deserve. It’s not a stacked release, but a few good extras beat a bare-bones disc every time.
This is 100% Shelf Worthy. For current fans, it’s a no-brainer, a prestigious slot for a show that earned one. If you’ve never met Julie and Billy, queue up a few episodes on Hulu first. This is comedy that refuses to use its indoor voice, and you’ll know within an episode or two whether that’s your kind of loud. If it clicks, the complete series belongs on your shelf. Three seasons was never going to be enough. I still hold out hope for a fourth season to be announced or a movie to get the green light — it shouldn’t be that difficult.
Looking for something? Search for it here! Try an actor, movie, director, genre, or keyword!
Leave a Reply