SPOILER-FREE FILM REVIEWS FROM A MOVIE LOVER WITH A HEART OF GOLD!

From the land of 10,000 lakes comes a fan of 10,000 movies!

Club Kid Review: Rave New Dad

Reggie Absolom as Arlo hugging Jordan Firstman as Peter at the kitchen table in Club Kid
Club Kid poster

Movie Review

Club Kid

7/10

TLDR

Jordan Firstman’s Club Kid is energetic, funny, surprisingly tender, and occasionally as exhausting as spending an evening babysitting somebody else’s child. A terrific cast and Firstman’s confident direction make it an enormously entertaining trip through New York nightlife, even as the screenplay brushes aside consequences that probably deserved more attention. It’s a lot of fun while it lasts, but I was also happy to get home and enjoy a little peace and quiet.

Where to watch: In theaters. A24 began its limited release November 6, with a nationwide expansion November 25.

The Facts

Synopsis: When a hard-partying New York City club promoter discovers he has a 10-year-old son he never knew existed, his carefully cultivated life of late nights, loud music, and questionable decisions is turned upside down by someone who actually needs him to be responsible.

Director: Jordan Firstman

Stars: Jordan Firstman, Reggie Absolom, Diego Calva, Cara Delevingne, Kirby Howell-Baptiste, Colleen Camp

Rated: R for drug content throughout, strong sexual content, brief graphic nudity, and language throughout

Running Length: 122 minutes

The Thoughts

Jordan Firstman is having the kind of year most writer-directors would happily trade their firstborn for, which is a particularly inappropriate expression to use when discussing his new film, Club Kid. After appearing in Rachel Sennott‘s HBO comedy I Love LA, Firstman brought his feature directorial debut to the Un Certain Regard section at Cannes, where it reportedly received a seven-minute standing ovation and sparked a bidding war that A24 eventually won with a deal worth approximately $17 million. That’s an impressive amount of enthusiasm for a movie about a New York party promoter who discovers he has a 10-year-old son and suddenly has to figure out how to be a parent. Fortunately, much of that enthusiasm is justified. Club Kid is energetic, moving, frequently hilarious, and sometimes downright exhausting.

The closest comparison I can make is babysitting. Spending an evening with somebody else’s child can be a wonderful time. You dance around the living room, let them stay up a little later than you probably should, and laugh at things you wouldn’t ordinarily find amusing. Then the volume gets louder, the sugar kicks in, and the questions start coming faster than you can answer them. You love the experience, but there’s also a certain relief when the parents come home and you can return to your own place, where nobody is asking you to explain what happens when you die. Firstman’s movie has much the same effect, and for most of its running time, I mean that as a compliment.

Bottle Service Meets Bedtime

Firstman, who first attracted attention through his viral pandemic-era comedy sketches, writes, directs, and stars as Peter, a gay New York City club promoter whose life revolves around an elaborate nightlife scene he’s helped create in Bushwick. Alongside his business partner Sophie (Cara Delevingne, Suicide Squad), he throws a monthly party at the fictional Club Labor, where the music is deafening, the personalities are enormous, and practically everyone seems to know him. Peter has built a world that operates according to his own schedule, and he likes it that way. Then his old friend Edison (Kirby Howell-Baptiste, Cruella) arrives from London with a rather substantial surprise: a 10-year-old boy named Arlo (Reggie Absolom), who happens to be Peter’s son.

Arlo’s mother has died, Edison needs to return to London, and Peter suddenly finds himself responsible for a grieving child he didn’t know existed. It’s a remarkable interruption to a lifestyle that doesn’t appear to include many regular sleeping hours, much less school schedules, grocery shopping, or the sort of steady emotional attention a child actually requires. Peter is barely equipped to look after himself, yet he’s now trying to keep his nightlife business running while dealing with custody questions, immigration complications, and a young boy who has considerably more reason to be confused than anybody around him. For a man accustomed to being the center of attention, discovering that somebody else’s needs might have to come first is a pretty substantial adjustment.

The premise isn’t exactly new. We’ve seen variations on the irresponsible bachelor suddenly becoming a father in everything from Three Men and a Baby to Big Daddy, but Firstman gives the material a personality all its own by placing it within a queer New York community that rarely gets this kind of mainstream attention. Peter isn’t surrounded by conventional family members who arrive to teach him how to change diapers and behave like a responsible adult. He’s surrounded by club kids, artists, performers, and friends whose lives are every bit as unconventional as his own. The question becomes whether these people can create a stable home for Arlo without abandoning everything that makes their community special.

Three members of Peter’s nightlife crew at a party in Club Kid

A Night Out in New York

One of the film’s greatest strengths is how completely it captures the atmosphere of New York nightlife. Firstman worked with producer Alex Coco, who helped bring Anora to the screen, and there’s a similar interest in mixing professional actors with people who actually inhabit the world being depicted. Rather than populate his clubs entirely with extras pretending to be regulars, Firstman cast performers and nightlife personalities he encountered around the city, including Miss Benny and Alaska Riley. Amanda Lepore, Kandy Muse, and Linux also make appearances during the opening party, creating the kind of scene where you’re not entirely sure whether you’re watching a movie or somebody has simply handed you an invitation to a very exclusive Friday night.

The result is enormously convincing, although the opening stretch practically assaults the senses. The music is relentless, the conversations are conducted at approximately the volume of a departing airplane, and every room seems illuminated by enough neon and strobe lights to power a small city. Firstman wants us to feel the excitement and excess of Peter’s world, and he certainly accomplishes that. I found myself occasionally longing for the characters to take a seat somewhere with reasonably flattering lighting and speak to each other at a normal volume, but there’s something wonderfully immersive about the experience. If you’ve ever wondered what it feels like to be the oldest person in a room full of enthusiastic clubgoers, Club Kid provides a remarkably accurate simulation.

The film’s sense of authenticity extends beyond the nightlife itself. Peter’s apartment, a large, cluttered loft on the Lower East Side, feels like a place somebody has actually inhabited for years rather than a production designer’s idea of how an eccentric New Yorker should live. Within the story, his late mother was an artist who secured the apartment decades earlier for $600 a month, which might be the most fantastical element in a movie filled with questionable decisions. The production found the location just days before filming, near Allen and Canal Streets, and filled it with the books, plants, artwork, and accumulated oddities that suggest a real life. Production designer Stephen Phelps, whose work includes Anora, reportedly received a crash course in Butt magazine and Monstera plants to get the details right. The result is a home that feels welcoming without ever looking particularly childproof.

A Cast Worth Staying Up For

Firstman is a tremendously appealing presence in his own film, giving Peter a sharp comic personality that gradually reveals a surprising amount of vulnerability. He’s clearly comfortable making himself the center of attention, but he’s also willing to let the character look selfish, foolish, and occasionally overwhelmed. Reggie Absolom, a young actor from Oxford whose previous credits include Silo, is equally effective as Arlo, bringing an appealing naturalness to a role that could easily have been written as an adorable collection of precocious one-liners. Their relationship is the film’s emotional center, and Firstman wisely allows them moments of ordinary companionship away from the clubs, where getting to know one another becomes more important than the next outrageous party.

The supporting cast is equally enjoyable. Delevingne is a good match for Firstman’s manic energy as Sophie, a woman who understands Peter’s world but isn’t entirely convinced he’s prepared for the responsibilities that have arrived on his doorstep. Saturn Risin9, a DJ and performer Firstman discovered in a club, makes a terrific impression as Saffron, who helps introduce Arlo to the art of working the decks. Diego Calva (On Swift Horses) brings a welcome softness to Oscar, the social worker assigned to Arlo’s case who gradually develops an attraction to Peter. Their scenes have a warmth that becomes increasingly important as the film moves away from the constant stimulation of the opening act and starts allowing its characters to consider what they actually want from one another.

And then there’s Colleen Camp, who may be my favorite unexpected pleasure in the entire film. With a career stretching across roughly 200 movies and five decades, including the immortal Clue, Camp has certainly earned the right to turn up wherever she pleases and make things interesting. She plays Evelyn, Peter’s downstairs neighbor, the kind of New Yorker who seems to have been living in the same apartment since before the city invented zoning laws. Firstman reportedly met her after a screening of Rotting in the Sun, and their subsequent encounter at the Chateau Marmont sounds every bit as eccentric as the character she plays. Her odd little romance with Nicky (Eldar Isgandarov, whom I also caught in The Debut at TIFF), a houseguest Peter sends downstairs after Arlo arrives, is an absolute delight. I’d happily watch another movie about those two taking a drive in the country.

When the Music Softens

Cinematographer Adam Newport-Berra, whose work also includes The Invite, shot Club Kid on 35mm film, giving the movie a visual texture that helps distinguish it from the barrage of digital nightlife imagery we’re accustomed to seeing. He draws inspiration from New York films such as Cruising and An Unmarried Woman, capturing the city as something vibrant, unpredictable, and occasionally overwhelming. What’s especially impressive is how the photography changes as Peter begins adjusting to Arlo’s presence. The opening scenes are dominated by flashing lights, crowded dance floors, and frenetic camera movement, while the later sequences become softer and more composed. Ordinary stores, restaurants, and quiet moments inside the apartment gradually replace the chaos of the clubs, as though the camera itself is learning how to settle down.

The music plays an equally important role, with Firstman reportedly assembling a playlist before he even began writing the screenplay. A singalong to Rihanna‘s “Sex with Me” in the back of an Uber captures the ridiculous exuberance of Peter’s social circle, while Ethel Cain‘s “Thoroughfare” becomes a surprisingly affecting moment between Peter and Arlo. The Rihanna track apparently proved particularly difficult to license, requiring some assistance from the singer’s former stylist, Mel Ottenberg. Cristobal Tapia de Veer, whose credits include The White Lotus and Babygirl, provides the score, while the production filmed in actual clubs and parties around New York, with Brooklyn’s Market Hotel standing in for Club Labor. Editors Taylor Levy and Sofía Subercaseaux keep the energy moving, although they wisely allow the film to breathe once the emotional story begins taking precedence.

All Rave, No Repercussions

For all the things Club Kid does wonderfully, there’s a frustrating tendency to introduce complications and then hurry past them before anyone has to deal with the consequences. Peter’s sudden introduction to fatherhood should create all sorts of practical and emotional difficulties, particularly for a man whose lifestyle has been built around avoiding responsibility. Yet he and Arlo rarely experience the kind of genuine conflict that might force either character to confront how dramatically their lives have changed. They get along remarkably well, and while that’s certainly pleasant to watch, it also makes the transition from party boy to parent feel considerably easier than it should.

A particularly troubling incident involving violence between Arlo and another boy is never explored with the seriousness it deserves, and the film occasionally seems to forget that a child experiencing grief might have needs that can’t be addressed through affection, good music, and a few supportive friends. There are also nagging questions about school, custody, and the timeline of Arlo’s arrival, particularly as various authorities become involved in determining his future. I’m not suggesting that every movie about parenthood needs to include a lengthy discussion of paperwork and educational requirements, but a little more attention to the reality of this arrangement would have made the emotional developments considerably more convincing.

Firstman seems to understand exactly how much he can get away with, counting on the audience to be so entertained by his characters that we won’t stop to question the things the screenplay conveniently sidesteps. And to his credit, that approach works more often than it probably should. The people are enormously appealing, the humor is frequently terrific, and there’s a genuine tenderness to Peter’s developing relationship with Arlo. Yet I kept wishing somebody would sit everyone down for five minutes and give them a much-needed reality check. It’s one thing to celebrate a community coming together to raise a child. It’s another to suggest that good intentions are enough to solve every problem that comes with it.

Growing Up Without Growing Old

What ultimately makes Club Kid worth seeing is its affection for the people inhabiting this world and its understanding that becoming responsible doesn’t necessarily mean surrendering the parts of yourself that make life enjoyable. Peter doesn’t need to abandon his friends or transform himself into a conventional suburban father to become someone Arlo can depend on. He needs to recognize that another person’s happiness and well-being now matter just as much as his own. There’s something genuinely touching about watching a community accustomed to late nights and unconventional relationships begin making space for a child, particularly when that child gradually becomes part of the family they’ve built together.

I wish Firstman trusted that emotional material enough to explore its complications more thoroughly, because his film is capable of much more than simply entertaining us. Still, it’s a remarkably confident debut, full of engaging performances, wonderfully specific details, and moments of unexpected sweetness. It also makes New York look like the sort of place where anything can happen, including a nightclub promoter accidentally discovering he might be a pretty decent father. I laughed, I was moved, and I occasionally wanted to send everybody to their rooms without dessert. That’s a pretty successful night out, even if I was ready for a little peace and quiet by the time it ended.

Club Kid opened in select theaters November 6 and expands nationwide through A24 on November 25.

Jordan Firstman as Peter holding a bowl in his loft kitchen while Reggie Absolom as Arlo eats in Club Kid

The Final

Club Kid is loud, funny, frequently exhausting, and surprisingly touching, with a terrific ensemble and a confident debut from Jordan Firstman. Its biggest weakness is how easily the screenplay lets everyone off the hook, particularly when the realities of parenthood threaten to interrupt the party. But there’s enough warmth and personality here to make the experience worthwhile. As with babysitting, I had a wonderful time. I was also pretty happy when somebody finally turned the music down.

7/10

Where to watch: In theaters (A24; limited November 6, wide November 25)

Joe Botten, The MN Movie Man

Reviewed by Joe Botten

Joe Botten is The MN Movie Man, a Twin Cities film critic writing spoiler-free reviews since 2012. He also writes for Loud and Clear Reviews, a Rotten Tomatoes approved site. Find him on Instagram and Letterboxd.

Looking for something?

Search by actor, movie, director, genre or keyword.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 5,241 other subscribers
Where to watch Club Kid

Leave a Reply