SPOILER-FREE FILM REVIEWS FROM A MOVIE LOVER WITH A HEART OF GOLD!

From the land of 10,000 lakes comes a fan of 10,000 movies!

Victorian Psycho Review: Good Help Is Dead

Maika Monroe as Winifred Notty in Victorian Psycho

Movie Review

Victorian Psycho

7/10

TLDR

Maika Monroe is gloriously unhinged as a governess whose employment history probably wouldn’t survive a background check. Victorian Psycho has a wicked sense of humor, some striking nighttime photography, and a finale that really delivers. The limited budget and uneasy shifts between satire and slaughter occasionally show, and its violence involving children won’t be for everyone, but Monroe makes this one very strange house call worth taking.

Where to watch: In theaters now

The Facts

Synopsis: In 1858, an eccentric young governess arrives at an isolated English manor to care for two children. As members of the household begin disappearing, the family discovers its newest employee may be considerably more dangerous than her references suggested.

Director: Zachary Wigon, from a screenplay by Virginia Feito based on her novel

Stars: Maika Monroe, Thomasin McKenzie, Ruth Wilson, Jason Isaacs, Jacobi Jupe, and Evie Templeton

Rated: R for strong bloody violence and brief sexual material

Running Length: 102 minutes

The Thoughts

If you’re going to hire a governess for your children in a remote Victorian mansion, you might want to check her references. Thoroughly. In Victorian Psycho, a young woman named Winifred Notty arrives at Ensor House in 1858 with a peculiar manner, an even more peculiar relationship with the truth, and the sort of smile that suggests somebody should have locked the silverware away before she came through the door. Soon enough, members of the household begin disappearing, and the Pounds family slowly considers the possibility that their new employee might not be entirely suited to childcare. I won’t say much more about what happens inside the house, because the pleasure of this very twisted movie comes from watching Maika Monroe take an apparently familiar gothic heroine and turn her into the last person you’d want looking after your children.

The premise sounds like Jane Eyre wandered into American Psycho and came out with a body count, which is more or less the kind of trouble writer Virginia Feito has in mind. Feito adapted her own novel, published in 2025, for director Zachary Wigon, who previously explored a very different kind of power struggle in Sanctuary. Margaret Qualley was originally attached to play Winifred before Monroe took over, and after watching the finished film I have a hard time imagining anybody else making this particular combination of composure, mischief, and homicidal impulse work quite so well. The movie announces its off-center personality immediately, and whether you enjoy the next 102 minutes will depend largely on how much you appreciate the spectacle of good manners being subjected to very bad behavior.

The Governess From Hell

Monroe has spent much of her horror career being pursued, stalked, or terrorized. In It Follows, Watcher, and especially Longlegs, she gave us women whose fear was convincing because they were smart enough to recognize the danger but couldn’t always get away from it. Here, for a change, she’s the reason everybody else should be afraid. It’s a terrific reversal, and Monroe has a ball with it without ever suggesting she’s simply enjoying a costume-party excursion into madness. Her performance is made up of little decisions: a pause that lasts too long, a glance that doesn’t quite reach the person she’s looking at, or a smile that remains fixed after the conversation has turned distinctly unpleasant. Then something violent happens, and she reacts as though the maid has spilled the tea.

Monroe has mentioned Jack Nicholson in The Shining as an influence, and you can see why. The trick isn’t merely making someone frightening, but allowing us to recognize the pleasure they take in making everyone else uncomfortable. There’s a similar air of calculated performance here, although Winifred’s motives aren’t always clear, and I occasionally wanted a better sense of who she was before she arrived at Ensor House. Her surname is pronounced like “naughty,” which is either the least subtle character name imaginable or a very good indication that Feito knows precisely what kind of joke she’s telling. Monroe’s accent wanders a little, but her wonderfully unnerving presence is so consistent that the uncertainty almost feels appropriate. I wouldn’t object to spending more time with Winifred in another film, although I suspect everyone involved should insist on hazard pay.

Winifred Notty and a woman in a nightgown by candlelight in Victorian Psycho

Mind Your Manners, Mind Your Neck

Most gothic stories ask us to worry about what might happen to a young woman entering an imposing country estate. The Innocents, which remains a perfect 10 in my book, understands how terrifying a house full of secrets can be for a governess. Victorian Psycho turns that arrangement inside out. The governess is the secret, and the house is in trouble. Feito uses the rigid etiquette of nineteenth-century society, particularly the expectation that women should be deferential, grateful, and appropriately restrained, as both a punch line and a fuse. Winifred can smile politely while imagining terrible things, and the more the family attempts to maintain appearances, the funnier and more disturbing the whole arrangement becomes.

There’s an intriguing thread of class resentment and suppressed female anger here, with a little of the eat-the-rich nastiness of Saltburn and The Menu dressed up in Victorian clothes. But the movie also wants to be a brutal slasher, and those ambitions don’t always make comfortable companions. I can get behind a gleefully inappropriate joke about upper-class hypocrisy, and I can appreciate a film that isn’t afraid to turn genuinely ugly. The trouble is that some of the violence, especially when children are involved, lands with so little explanation or emotional context that it becomes unpleasant rather than revealing. The movie occasionally seems unsure whether we’re supposed to laugh, recoil, or study Winifred as a psychological case. A sharp-tongued cook or scandalized aunt might have helped the comedy breathe between the bloodletting. At Ensor House, everybody could use a little more comic relief, preferably someone who survives long enough to deliver it.

A House With Mixed Lighting

The production doesn’t always look as expensive as its ambitions. Ensor House is an imposing location, and filming in Ireland gives the setting an attractive authenticity, but there’s a theatrical quality to some of the costumes and interiors that makes the household look a bit like a group of friends has borrowed the manor for a very elaborate Halloween party. The problem is particularly apparent in daylight, when the bright, sometimes washed-out photography exposes details that might have benefited from a little mystery. At night, however, Nico Aguilar’s cinematography becomes a considerable asset. Candlelight throws uneasy shadows across faces and corridors, and the grounds seem to be concealing something that doesn’t necessarily want to remain concealed. The movie looks far more convincing after everybody has gone to bed, which is also when I’d least want to be staying there.

Ariel Marx’s score helps enormously, mixing period-flavored music with more unsettling textures that make the house feel unstable even when the characters insist on behaving normally. Wigon also uses overlapping, nearly indecipherable whispers to draw us into Winifred’s increasingly fractured interior world. Sometimes it’s difficult to identify whether we’re hearing her voice or somebody else’s, and the confusion gives the film a creepiness that a straightforward explanation couldn’t. The supporting cast has a much harder assignment than Monroe, largely because its members have to react to a character who’s operating on a completely different frequency. Jason Isaacs and Ruth Wilson are effective as Mr. and Mrs. Pounds, Jacobi Jupe (Hamnet) plays their son Andrew, and Thomasin McKenzie (Jojo Rabbit, Last Night in Soho) gives Ms. Lamb a suitably wary presence. They’re good company, even if this particular household makes a compelling argument for finding employment elsewhere.

A Bloody Good Exit

For all the unevenness, Victorian Psycho knows how to make an exit. The film’s chaptered structure gives the proceedings a brisk, almost storybook rhythm, and Wigon saves some of his most striking visual ideas for the final stretch. There’s a beautiful, disturbing image of transition before the story reaches its conclusion, and from there the movie finally brings its visual confidence, grotesque humor, and interest in Winifred’s inner life into alignment. It’s the kind of ending that can make you look more kindly on the rough patches that preceded it, partly because you leave the theater thinking about the images rather than the places where the budget was showing.

I wouldn’t call the film a complete success. Its tone wanders, the violence goes places some viewers will have no interest in following, and not every idea receives the attention it deserves. But Monroe is sensational, and there’s real imagination in turning a gothic governess story into an exercise in dangerous bad manners. She’s spent years proving how convincingly she can be frightened. Now she’s just as convincing frightening everybody else. If Feito and Wigon ever want to tell us what Winifred was doing before she applied for this job, I’ll be first in line. And I’ll be checking the references myself.

A woman in a gold gown screaming by candlelight in Victorian Psycho

The Final

Victorian Psycho is uneven, occasionally cheap-looking, and extremely bloody, but Maika Monroe makes its murderous governess impossible to ignore. The night photography, Ariel Marx’s music, and a terrific finale help this wicked little gothic nightmare overcome its rough edges. Children and sensitive viewers should steer clear. Everyone else might want to keep an eye on the new help.

7/10

Where to watch: In theaters now

Joe Botten, The MN Movie Man

Reviewed by Joe Botten

Joe Botten is The MN Movie Man, a Twin Cities film critic writing spoiler-free reviews since 2012. He also writes for Loud and Clear Reviews, a Rotten Tomatoes approved site. Find him on Instagram and Letterboxd.

Looking for something?

Search by actor, movie, director, genre or keyword.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 5,241 other subscribers
Where to watch Victorian Psycho

Leave a Reply